idea-evaluator
idea-evaluator is a Peer review & grants skill for AI agents, published by HKUSTDial in the Supervisor-Skills repository on GitHub. Skillspace rates idea-evaluator C (72/100) and it passed the safety scan; the rating is based on static analysis only.
Evaluates a preliminary research idea against a five-dimension framework (Higher, Faster, Stronger, Cheaper, Broader) plus idea-lifecycle and student-capability matching, paradigm-shift probing, and a fatal-flaws audit. Returns a reviewer-style verdict; non-STEM ideas route to substitute frameworks. Use when the user has a draft research idea and asks whether it is worth pursuing, asks to 'evaluate this idea', 'score this idea', 'assess feasibility', 'novelty check', 'is this a good research direction', or before committing to a paper scope.
- Grade
- C
- Quality
- 72 / 100
- Safety
- Passed
- GitHub stars
- 3,997
Unproven: rated by static analysis only, not yet compared head-to-head.
Our two independent classifiers differ on this skill's category, so treat the placement as provisional.
This rating describes the version of the repository we crawled; it may have changed since, so go by its current files.
Our review
- Architecture
- 84 / 100
- Maturity
- Packaged: licensed, with a version or references
- Security scan
- No issues found
- License
- Not declared. Check the repository before reusing it.
- Adoption
- Adopted by 0 other repositories, in 0 collections
- Scope
- Portable: works in any project. General research-idea evaluation framework, reusable anywhere
Not checked yet
- Not judged on the rubric yet (not a contender in its category)
- No blind task eval yet
- Sibling files (scripts, references) not fetched; security scan covers SKILL.md only
Skillspace indexes and rates this skill; it does not host or endorse it. Run third-party skills at your own risk.