light-idea-critique
light-idea-critique is a Peer review & grants skill for AI agents, published by Light0305 in the Light-skills repository on GitHub. Skillspace rates light-idea-critique D (69/100) and it passed the safety scan; the rating is based on static analysis only.
Light 科研主线第 4 步·审 idea：以**顶会审稿人标准严审** idea，**撞车/无创新 fatal flaw 一票否决**(critical 门)， 逼出真能发表的 idea。何时用：用户问"这 idea 行不行/够不够新/能不能发""帮我严审/挑刺/找致命问题" / idea 定稿前把关 / 收到 idea-generation 的候选要审 / 怀疑撞车(被人做过)。触发词：审 idea / 评审 / 严审 / 挑刺 / 这 idea 行不行 / 够不够新 / 创新性 / 撞车 / 被做过了吗 / 致命问题 / 能投顶会吗 / 拒稿风险 / critique my idea / review this idea / is this novel / fatal flaw / 一票否决。核心纪律：**撞车/无创新的 critical 一票否决在本技能**(不被其他高维度平均救回)； **硬性反谄媚**(不被作者反复反驳顺从放行弱 idea)；撞车判定**target/background 可追溯分解**非"感觉像"；judge 不靠裸 自评(用可计算否决闸门 + 密度先验 + pairwise)。**消费上游 idea-generation 的撞车 findings + facet 槽位**。
- Grade
- D
- Quality
- 69 / 100
- Safety
- Passed
- GitHub stars
- 445
Unproven: rated by static analysis only, not yet compared head-to-head.
Our two independent classifiers differ on this skill's category, so treat the placement as provisional.
This rating describes the version of the repository we crawled; it may have changed since, so go by its current files.
Our review
- Architecture
- 78 / 100
- Maturity
- Structured: ships references or scripts
- Security scan
- No issues found
- License
- MIT
- Adoption
- Adopted by 0 other repositories, in 0 collections
- Scope
- Repo-internal: written for the repository it lives in. DAG stage 4 of this repo's own 'Light' research pipeline system.
Not checked yet
- Not judged on the rubric yet (not a contender in its category)
- No blind task eval yet
- Sibling files (scripts, references) not fetched; security scan covers SKILL.md only
Skillspace indexes and rates this skill; it does not host or endorse it. Run third-party skills at your own risk.