scholar-evaluation
scholar-evaluation is a Peer review & grants skill for AI agents, published by foryourhealth111-pixel in the Vibe-Skills repository on GitHub. Skillspace rates scholar-evaluation B (84/100) and it passed the safety scan; a judge model has also reviewed it.
Systematically evaluate scholarly work using the ScholarEval framework, providing structured assessment across research quality dimensions including problem formulation, methodology, analysis, and writing with quantitative scoring and actionable feedback.
- Grade
- B
- Quality
- 84 / 100
- Safety
- Passed
- GitHub stars
- 2,381
Placed #1 of 2 when judged against its near-duplicates in Peer review & grants.
Not launch-quality. It is graded B with a clean safety verdict, but our quality filters exclude it: it is a near-duplicate variant of another skill. So it is not in our launch-quality set, the skills our MCP server searches and recommends. How launch-quality is decided
Our two independent classifiers differ on this skill's category, so treat the placement as provisional.
This rating describes the version of the repository we crawled; it may have changed since, so go by its current files.
Our review
- Architecture
- 94 / 100
- Maturity
- Packaged: licensed, with a version or references
- Security scan
- No issues found
- License
- Apache-2.0
- Adoption
- Adopted by 0 other repositories, in 2 collections
- Scope
- Portable: works in any project. General ScholarEval framework for evaluating any scholarly research work.
Judge review
Placed #1 of 2 when judged against its near-duplicates in Peer review & grants.
- Trigger
75 75 - Instructions
67 67 - Specificity
78 78 - Safety
33 33 - Disclosure
56 56 - Maintenance
45 45
Nearly identical to its sibling variant, but it fixes a real bug: the schematic-generation script path now points into the separate scientific-schematics skill instead of a non-existent local scripts folder.
Not checked yet
- No blind task eval yet
- Sibling files (scripts, references) not fetched; security scan covers SKILL.md only
Skillspace indexes and rates this skill; it does not host or endorse it. Run third-party skills at your own risk.